Sunday, December 2, 2007

Final Book Review #3: "123 for You and Me"


"123 for You and Me" by Meg Girnis is another book depicting a diverse group in literature. This book is a counting book that concentrates on children with Down Syndrome as they are photographed with a different number of objects on each page. I would consider Meg Girnis an insider to this topic because she has sister in law (that passed away in 1985) that had Downs Syndrome, and two children (one that has Down Syndrome and one that doesn't)as well. Both of her children are even pictured in this book on the "Seven Ducklings" page! What is great about the book is that while most of the children pictured do, in fact, have Down Syndrome, there are also many other children in the book that don't have Downs Syndrome. There are children of just about every ethnicity and culture as well. I really like how this book shows children of all diverse backgrounds featured in it with different objects. All the children appear to be having a great time as they are shown with fuzzy ducklings or presents or big hairy dogs. Like my other two books, this book also shows realistic photographs of the children which makes it easier for them to relate to the characters if compared to books with drawings or cartoons of children with the disability. Meg Girnis has also written another book as a conjunction with this book called, "ABC for You and Me". This book depicts children primarily with Down Syndrome with different letters of the alphabet. I really like the idea of depicting children with disabilities as characters in books like counting or letter books. Until I've researched this book, I've never seen a child with a disability portrayed in a resource book like this. I think it's great to depict children of all backgrounds in these types of resource books and I feel that it shows other children that children with disabilities can be relatable to them as well.



Girnis, Meg. 123 for You and Me. Morton Grove, IL: Albert Whitman & Company, 2000.

Final Book Review #2: "Big Brother Dustin"


Alden Carter, himself, is an insider to this subject because his wife, Carol, (who did the photography for this book) was a social worker her whole life and has dealt with many families that are having troubles with disabilities in their families. The Carter's often spent many dinner conversations about what was happening with Carol's clients at work. The Carters are very familiar with disabilities and often travel around the country talking about their experiences with disability and what it's like to write about it for children.

"Big Brother Dustin" by Alden R. Carter, is a book about a young boy with Down Syndrome (Dustin) that finds out that he will soon have a new baby sister and finds out that his mother is pregnant. Dustin's parents are unsure of what to name the baby that is on the way, so they appoint Dustin to the job of coming up with the perfect name for her. Dustin talks to both of his grandparents and wants to somehow name his new baby sister after both of his grandmother's (because he likes their names, "Anne" and "Mary")but is unsure of which name to choose. In the meantime, Dustin learns all about how to be a big brother by learning how to change diapers, how to pick out baby clothes, and how to set up a crib for his new sister. Dustin hates waiting so long for his new sister to be born, but in the meantime he comes up with the perfect name for his new sister. Dustin thinks that MaryAnn would be the perfect name since it has both of his grandmother's names in it. His parents love this idea and agree to name the new baby MaryAnn. Finally, when Dustin is staying at his grandparent's house, he hears that his mom and dad are at the hospital and that his new baby sister was born overnight! Dustin picks out flowers for his mom at the hospital and a balloon for his new sister. Dustin meets his sister for the first time and the following pages are pictures of Dustin and MaryAnn playing together. Much like "Where's Chimpy?", "Big Brother Dustin" uses real life photographs of Dustin, his family, and his new baby sister. The pictures make the story more realistic and make Dustin more identifiable to readers that may or may not have a disability themselves. I really enjoyed this book as a piece of diverse literature because, once again, there is no mention that Dustin has a disability. Instead, the book focuses on Dustin as a regular child that is excited for his new baby sister! We see that when the new baby is born she doesn't have Down Syndrome. The following pages depict how well Dustin and MaryAnn get along when they are playing together despite Dustin's disability. I think that this is an important message for young readers and that this book would be great for students to see how even though Dustin has a disability, he is still very similar to non-disabled children and able to establish a positive relationship with his newborn sister.



Carter, Alden R.. Big Brother Dustin. 1983. Morton Grove, IL: Albert Whitman & Company, 1997.

Final Book Review #1: "Where's Chimpy?"


"Where's Chimpy" by Berniece Rabe, is a children's book that has a main character as a girl who has Down Syndrome. The book opens with a brief explanation of what Down Syndrome is from the National Down Syndrome Congress (this could be good for a discussion on what the disabilty is before the book is read to a class). I really enjoyed this book, overall. I love that the author got her inspiration for this book from looking outside of her window to see her neighbor playing with his daughter who has Down Syndrome. Berniece said, "I must do a story about Misty and her daddy-a story other children with Down Syndrome can identify with. I want her to have the lead role, not the secondary role usually allocated to children with this handicap" (found in the appendex of "Where's Chimpy"). Misty's role is just that in this story. With realistic photographs of Misty and her father, this book really comes to life and portrays Misty as a "normal" child. There is no mention of Misty having a disability in this book, yet plenty of examples of how Misty lives out her daily life as a normal child. I like that this book doesn't mention or concentrate on the fact that Misty has a disabillity. This book makes Misty relatable to other children that may be reading the book, which I feel is a positive aspect for this text. The book is about Misty's father tucking Misty into bed when Misty realizes that her favorite stuffed animal, Chimpy, is missing. Misty can't go to bed without her favorite monkey stuffed animal so her dad and her re-trace Misty's daily activities to try and find the stuffed monkey. What's humorous is that when Misty goes back to all of the places she was earlier that day, she ends up finding other toys that she thought were lost. For example, she went back to her sandbox to look for Chimpy but found her ditch digger toy. There are also pictures that flashback to Misty playing at these places with other children that don't have any disabilities. I think this also shows a positive message of acceptance when we see Misty and the other children playing together; this could be a positive message for young readers to see in this text, as well. Another interesting aspect to this story is that the reader is only introduced to Misty and her father. Does this mean that Misty lives with a single dad? I feel that this could also be another way to incorporate this text as a diverse piece of literature. At the end of the book, Misty finally finds Chimpy in the bathroom when she remembers that she left him in there when she took her bath. Misty can finally fall asleep now that she has her favorite stuffed animal and dad can finally tuck her in. Overall, I feel that this book denotes a positive representation of a child with Down Syndrome and would use it in my classroom library in the future.



Rabe, Berniece. Where's Chimpy?. Niles, IL: Albert Whitman & Company , 1988.

Monday, November 12, 2007

Confessions of a Closet Catholic-Questioning the text

So here's a brief summary of what I wrote about for my questioning the text paper:

My question was , "What is the real reason for Jussie's desire to be Catholic? Is it because Jussie wanted to feel accepted/normal or was she just taking the steps towards embracing her own identity during adolescence?

I think that one of the major issues that lead Jussie towards Catholicism is the fact that she was in her adolescence and wanted to feel accepted or normal. It's important to note that during your adolescence, finding your identity is pretty much a crucial aspect of being a pre-teen. Jussie's longing for some sort of acceptance (since she doesn't get it at home from her parents) might have led her to try and become Catholic since one of her best friends is Catholic. Jussie is constantly talking about how she is a sort of "ugly misfit" and she can't understand why her friends are even friends with her at times. When Jussie talks about issues like this, it's apparent that she is still in the process of accepting her own uniqueness and needs to work on being proud of who she is as a person which is why dabbling in other religions could be a tool for helping Jussie find her true identity.

In my paper, I also talked about how Jussie is constantly comparing herself to her friend, Mac. Mac is seemly perfect according to Jussie. She has the perfect looks (with straight blond hair and blue eyes), the perfect family (with a mom that is easy to talk to and doesn't care about a messy house), and also the perfect siblings (that are easy to get along with and don't treat her like an outcast). It seems fair that because of the high regards that Jussie holds Mac in, that she would consider trying to become Catholic as well.

The last section of my paper is devoted to Kimmel's article about what it means for minority groups to find their own "Beal Streets". Kimmel said, “Embracing your identity brings great joy, along with a sense of wholeness, completion. ‘I know who I am and where I belong. These are my people". We can see when Jussie finds her "Beal Street" when she receives the Star of David necklace from her Bubbe. It is at this moment that Jussie can finally feel acceptance and feel as if she is a part of something (Judaism).

Tuesday, November 6, 2007

Project Mulberry

Overall, I enjoyed this book yet had some grievances with it as well. First, I'm not sure how I feel about the interjections between chapters. I do enjoy hearing about "behind the scene" info from the author, yet sometimes I felt that these chapters put akward haults into the text and disrupted the flow. Another concern I had with the text is that we as readers never really hear of Julie becoming accepting of her heritage at the end of the book. I can see how she feels more comfortable with her Korean heritage as her interest in embroidery grows, for example, yet I feel that I was looking for some closure with the topic and was waiting for her to say how she feels now about being Korean and how her project helped her embrace her culture. We also never really heard about Patrick's culture in the text. If heritage is such an important issue in this story, why isn't his heritage mentioned? The topic of Julie's mom's racism was also seemingly unresolved in this book. There are many loose ends that I feel weren't tied up as satisfyingly as I would have liked, but nevertheless it was a book I enjoyed and I was interested in the silk worm project especially.

Monday, October 22, 2007

My Final Project

For my final project I plan on focusing on disabilities, primarily with Downs Syndrome. The reason why I would like to focus on this subject is because my little brother (who actually isn't so little anymore, he's 16!) has Downs Syndrome and I have never really come across a book protraying this disability. I think it would be interesting to research these books and maybe even show them to my brother so he can read them and perhaps identify more with the characters; I know for a fact that he has never seen a book with character in it that has Downs Syndrome. It would be nice to see a character in a text with Downs Syndrome and see how the author protrays his/her character. I know first hand of what its like to grow up with a brother with special needs and it would be interesting to see other people's take on this experience!

Sunday, October 21, 2007

The Schneider Family Award

About: Given annually by the American Library Association. Honors an author or illustrator for the artistic expression of the disability experience for children and teen.There are 3 categories, which include birth-grade school, middle school, and teens
Purpose: To recognize quality literature in the area of physical, emotional, and/or mental disability.
Award Committee: 9 committee members are elected for 2 year terms. Chosen by executive board of the American Library Association based on recommendation.
Selection Criteria: The book must exhibit an aspect of living with a physical, mental, or emotional disability. It must also focus on artistic expression of children or adolescents living with a disability.
Previous winners and year awarded:Things Not Seen by Andrew Clements (2004)My Thirteenth Winter: A Memoir by Samantha Abeel (2005)Tending to Grace by Kimberly Newton Fusco (2006)